The Best Versions of Captain America Who Aren’t Steve Rogers, Ranked

[[{“value”:”

For many readers, Steve Rogers, aka Captain America, is the foundation upon which Marvel Comics was built. He’s an essential and memorable character, responsible for many iconic stories. However, as this is the world of comic books, there have been many iterations and variations, giving both Steve Rogers and Captain America a chance to change. For the latter, a dozen other heroes have carried the mantle.

Over the years, Steve Rogers has handed his shield off to other characters on numerous occasions, which has given rise to new stories with a different name behind the mantle. Likewise, the multiverse has opened the door to many different and surprising variations of Captain America.

10

Steve Mouser Was a Cat Version of Captain America

He’s Also Known As Captain Americat

First appeared in Marvel Tails Starring Peter Porker The Spectacular Spider-Ham #1 (1983)

Steven “Steven” Mouser

AKA Captain Americat or Cap

Peter Porker is a famous variant of the much beloved Spider-Man, but fans may not realize that Peter Porker isn’t alone in his universe. He has many superhero friends, including Steve Mouser, aka Captain Americat. Admittedly, it may be a little challenging to take this hero seriously, but that’s probably okay. He can save the day and give people a few laughs.

As a hero from Earth-8311, Captain Americat is a proud member of the Sca-vengers. Together, they have teamed up against many somewhat familiar villains, including the likes of Moletron. Steve Mouser is easily recognizable even in a crowd, thanks to his vibrant blue, red, and white uniform and iconic shield – and yes, in case it wasn’t obvious, he really is a cat.

9

Shannon Carter Briefly Served As Captain America

Shannon Carter’s Superhero Alias Was American Dream

First appeared in A-Next #4 (1998)

She’s Sharon Carter’s cousin

She hails from Earth-982

It’s safe to say that Peggy Carter has a fairly extended family. Even casual fans are likely familiar with Sharon Carter, thanks to the MCU, but then there’s Shannon Carter, Sharon’s cousin. She grew up idolizing the hero, thanks to all the tales she heard. So, naturally, in at least one universe, she became a hero in her own right. On Earth-982, Shannon Carter became her own version of Captain America, called American Dream.

They say one should never meet their heroes, but Shannon’s story proves that narrative false. Shannon Carter, as part of her universe’s Avengers, helped to save Earth-616’s Avengers. In other words, she finally got to meet her hero. Steve was so proud of this version that he insisted she carry the shield from her universe, bringing her story full circle.

8

Samantha Wilson Is Captain America In Spider-Gwen’s Universe

Like Steve Rogers, She Was Lost In Time

First appeared in Spider-Gwen #1 (2015)

Samantha T. Wilson, aka Captain America

She hails from Earth-65

Earth-65’s Gwen Stacy has gone through many hero names since her introduction, including Spider-Gwen. For a time, it even seemed like she was the only superhero in her world. Then, Samantha Wilson walked into the scene. Samantha Wilson is the Captain America of Earth-65, though her story is quite complicated. Samantha was one of four initial candidates for Project: Rebirth. While she was the final choice, she was lost to time, thanks to an interdimensional portal.

Seventy-five years later, she arrived just in time to be a new hero for Earth-65. Samantha immediately joined up with S.H.I.E.L.D. and began fighting the good fight, including helping to clean up a few of the villains, causing problems for Spider-Gwen. Like her counterparts, Samantha has battled her own version of Hydra.

Carol Is Usually Known as Captain Marvel

Captain America in Earth-18197

Captain America in Earth-2301 (Mangaverse)

Hard as it may be to believe, the hero best known for her role as Captain Marvel has spent some time carrying the title of Captain America. Since her introduction, Carol Danvers has gone by many hero names, including Ms. Marvel, Binary, Warbird, and, obviously, Captain Marvel. However, in two different universes, Carol is known by a different Captain title.

The first instance occurred during Marvel’s Mangaverse (Earth-2301), where readers will find a different version of Carol Danvers. This version doesn’t appear to be a Kree/human hybrid and instead appears more like Captain America in every way – title included. On Earth-18197, Carol Danvers’ likewise unfolded differently, resulting in her becoming Captain America – and a target of the Kree.

6

Roberta Mendez Is the Captain America of the Future

Roberta Is an Unwilling Hero from Earth-23291

First appeared in Secret Wars 2099 #1 (2015)

AKA Captain America 2099

Hails from Earth-23291

Roberta Mendez stands out in any Captain America lineup, and for one key reason—she never signed up for any of this. Roberta’s husband, Harry, forced his version of the Super-Soldier Serum on her, changing her path in life. With the serum coursing through her veins, Roberta became Captain America 2099, aka the Captain America of Earth-2099.

As Captain America 2099, Roberta Mendez became the leader of Alchemax’s version of the Avengers. Perhaps due to the unwilling nature of her transformation, Roberta developed a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde relationship with the Captain America persona. Additionally, much like some variations of the Winter Soldier, a specific combination of trigger words can control her. More specifically, these words can trigger her transformation between Roberta and Captain America.

5

Kiyoshi Morales Is a Genetically Modified Captain America

Kiyoshi Hails from Earth-11831

First appeared in Captain America Corps #1 (2011)

Hails from Earth-11831

AKA Commander A

Kiyoshi Morales is a hero hailing from Earth-11831, best known for his work with the Captain America Corps. Kiyoshi is a genetically modified version of Captain America and is one of five variations summoned by the Contemplator to serve in the Captain America Corps. As for his hero name, when he’s not going by Captain America or Kiyoshi, he’s called Commander A of the United Americas.

There’s still much to learn about Kiyoshi Morales and his story. Some people believe that he may be a descendant of Luke Cage, though his last name may make readers think of a different hero. One key difference for this version of Captain America is the shield, as instead of the one fans are more familiar with, Kiyoshi wields twin energy shields.

4

Danielle Cage Is the Daughter of Two Marvel Heroes

Danielle Serves As the Captain America for Earth-15061

First appeared (as Captain America) in Avengers: Ultron Forever #1 (2015)

She’s the daughter of Luke Cage and Jessica Jones

She’s from Earth-15061

Danielle Cage’s name likely sounds familiar to Jessica Jones and Luke Cage fans, as she’s their daughter. However, Earth-616’s Danielle is still a child, not Captain America. This version of Danielle hails from Earth-15061, where, at some point in the future, she stepped up to carry the mantle of Captain America. Thanks to her heritage, Danielle boasts a shocking variety of powers to back up her new title, including enhanced strength, durability, and telepathic resistance.

During the events of Avengers: Ultron Forever, Danielle’s version of Captain America gets to shine as she and other heroes are summoned to the future to battle against Ultron. Other iconic villains the hero has fought include the Golden Skull. Meanwhile, Danielle has joined the A.V.E.N.G.E.R.S. Initiative to help keep her world safe.

3

Peggy Carter Has Wielded Captain America’s Shield

Agent Carter From Another Earth

First appearance (as Captain America) in Exiles #3 (2018)

Margaret “Peggy” Carter

She hails from Earth-76

Most fans of Captain America will recognize Peggy Carter as the long-lost love interest for Steve Rogers; she played an important role in his early hero journey. However, her story goes very differently on Earth-76, where Peggy underwent the Super-Soldier Serum treatment following the tragic assassination of Steve Rogers and Professor Erskine. To honor their memory, she rose up and carried the mantle of Captain America.

Peggy Carter was born to be a hero, and her role as Captain America simply confirmed that. This version of the hero has appeared a few times, including Exiles (2018), Women of Marvel (2021), and the Disney+ animated series titled What If…? A different variation of this hero also appeared in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, though notably, this version is from Earth-838.

2

Bucky Barnes Isn’t Just Captain America’s Sidekick

He’s Been Winter Soldier and Captain America

First appeared as Captain America in Captain America #34 (2008)

James Buchanan “Bucky” Barnes

AKA Winter Soldier, Revolution, and Captain America

James “Bucky” Barnes has long been part of Steve Rogers’ story. They were best friends from a young age, and Bucky bore witness to Steve’s impressive transformation. While there’s no denying the two had their ups and downs, especially during Bucky’s time as the Winter Soldier, the two have held a bond that’ll last a lifetime. Originally introduced as Steve’s sidekick, Bucky has successfully become his own hero.

These days, most fans know Bucky as the Winter Solider or maybe even Revolution. However, he did have a stint as Captain America following the Civil War event. It wasn’t the most natural fit for this hero, as he’s a talented fighter, but Bucky is not always the best leader. Unsurprisingly, Bucky quickly returned the mantle to Steve Rogers upon the hero’s return.

1

Sam Wilson Might Be the Most Famous Alternate Captain America

He’s Been Known As Falcon and Captain America

First appeared as Captain America in Captain America #25 (2012)

Samuel Thomas “Sam” Wilson

Aka Captain America, Falcon, and Sammy

Thanks to the MCU, even the most casual Marvel fans are likely aware of how Sam Wilson becomes Captain America. However, it’s worth noting that the reasons for this transition are different between the comics and the MCU. In both versions, Sam was an incredibly loyal friend and ally to Steve Rogers, eventually making him the perfect replacement.

In the MCU, Sam Wilson hesitantly stepped into the role of Captain America following the events of Avengers: Endgame, while in the comics, Sam takes on the role after the super serum burns out of Steve Rogers’ body, effectively retiring the hero. Sam Wilson is an iconic version of Captain America, knowing full well he has massive shoes to fill. Likewise, his story is compelling, powerful, and worth the read.

“}]] Captain America is one of the most iconic Marvel Comics heroes, and a surprising number of heroes have stepped into Steve Rogers’ role.  Read More